Skip to content

Resources › Talent Development · 3 of 4

Develop & Evaluate

By RISE Business Framework · Created by Gary Harper and Brandon McCurdy · Reviewed

Developing and evaluating employees means regularly measuring performance and acting on what you find. RISE uses the 9-Box with a prescribed action for each box. Stars are promoted, Core Players are coached and Work Horses are maintained. The Up or Out Dilemma and Up & Out Grinder get a performance improvement plan (PIP).

How strong is your Resources quadrant? Take the free RISE Business Assessment

How RISE does it

  • The operative version of the 9-Box, with an action under every box.
  • High potential, low performance (Idle Genius): set expectations.
  • Two boxes call for a PIP: Up or Out Dilemma and Up & Out Grinder.
  • Bad Hire, the lowest box on both axes: move on.

Develop & Evaluate is one of four tools in Talent Development, part of the Resources quadrant of the RISE Business Framework.

The RISE tool

The 9-Box System: prescribed actions

Potential / PerformanceOneTwoThree
ThreeIdle Genius: set expectationsHigh Potential: invest in themStar: promote them
TwoUp or Out Dilemma: conduct a PIPCore Players: coach themHigh Performer: inspire them
OneBad Hire: move onUp & Out Grinder: conduct a PIPWork Horse: maintain

How to use the 9-Box grid for employee evaluations

The 9-Box grid turns an employee evaluation into a decision. Instead of a score that sits in a file, each person lands in a box with an action. RISE uses performance and potential, each rated one to three.

  1. 1

    Rate performance, 1 to 3

    How well do they deliver in their current role today? Use their numbers where you have them, such as the KPIs they own on the Stoplight Report.

  2. 2

    Rate potential, 1 to 3

    How far can they grow? RISE informs this with the Heart, Head, Hands and Feet assessments in Talent Optimization, especially the Mobility Assessment.

  3. 3

    Place them on the 9-Box

    Potential runs up the side and performance runs across the bottom. A three on both is a Star. Low on both is a Bad Hire.

  4. 4

    Apply the action for their box

    Promote Stars, invest in High Potential, inspire High Performers, coach Core Players, maintain Work Horses and set expectations for an Idle Genius. The Up or Out Dilemma and Up & Out Grinder get a PIP. A Bad Hire means move on.

  5. 5

    Fund development to match

    Use the $100 budget grid so investment follows the boxes. The Star gets $22; the Bad Hire gets $1.

  6. 6

    Re-rate at every review

    Track who moved and why. Movement between boxes is the real measure of whether development is working.

What a PIP looks like in RISE

A performance improvement plan is for the two boxes where something is clearly off: decent potential with low performance (Up or Out Dilemma) or decent performance with low potential (Up & Out Grinder). Set a clear target, a date and a check-in rhythm. At the end, the person moves up a box or out of the role.

The same grid, used three times

RISE uses the 9-Box to name where someone sits at Hire & Onboard, to prescribe an action here, and to allocate budget at Encourage & Recognize. The culture version, the Position Affirmation, uses the same axes.

AI RISE Coach

Work through Develop & Evaluate with the AI RISE Coach

“Walk me through Develop & Evaluate in the RISE Business Framework and help me apply it to my business.”

Ask the coach

Quick self-check

“We have a structured, ongoing program for developing team members after they are hired.”

Frequently asked questions

What should I do with an underperforming employee?

Find their box on the 9-Box first. RISE prescribes setting expectations for an Idle Genius and moving on from a Bad Hire. The Up or Out Dilemma and Up & Out Grinder get a PIP.

How do you use the 9-Box for performance reviews?

Rate each person 1-3 on potential and performance, find their box, and apply its action. Re-rate at each review to track movement.

Articles on Develop & Evaluate

The other tools in Talent Development

Related in another quadrant: Culture

Find out where your business really stands.

The free RISE Assessment scores your business across all four quadrants in about 6 minutes, and shows you where the opportunity is.

The RISE quadrant wheel